Vicious circle principle

Set theory

The vicious circle principle is a principle that was endorsed by many predicativist mathematicians in the early 20th century to prevent contradictions. The principle states that no object or property may be introduced by a definition that depends on that object or property itself. In addition to ruling out definitions that are explicitly circular (like "an object has property P iff it is not next to anything that has property P"), this principle rules out definitions that quantify over domains which include the entity being defined. Thus, it blocks Russell's paradox, which defines a set R that contains all sets which don't contain themselves. This definition is blocked because it defines a new set in terms of the totality of all sets, of which this new set would itself be a member. However, it also blocks one standard definition of the natural numbers. First, we define a property as being "hereditary" if, whenever a number n has the property, so does n +1. Then we say that x has the property of being a natural number if and only if it has every hereditary property that 0 has. This definition is blocked, because it defines "natural number" in terms of the totality of all hereditary properties, but "natural number" itself would be such a hereditary property, so the definition is circular in this sense. Most modern mathematicians and philosophers of mathematics think that this particular definition is not circular in any problematic sense, and thus they reject the vicious circle principle. But it was endorsed by many early 20th-century researchers, including Bertrand Russell and Henri Poincaré. On the other hand, Frank P. Ramsey and Rudolf Carnap accepted the ban on explicit circularity, but argued against the ban on circular quantification. After all, the definition "let T be the tallest man in the room" defines T by means of quantification over a domain (men in the room) of which T is a member. But this is not problematic, they suggest, because the definition doesn't actually create the person, but merely shows how to pick him out of the totality. Similarly, they suggest, definitions don't actually create sets or properties or objects, but rather just give one way of picking out the already existing entity from the collection of which it is a part. Thus, this sort of circularity in terms of quantification can't cause any problems. This principle was the reason for Russell's development of the ramified theory of types rather than the theory of simple types. (See "Ramified Hierarchy and Impredicative Principles".) An analysis of the paradoxes to be avoided shows that they all result from a kind of vicious circle. The vicious circles in question arise from supposing that a collection of objects may contain members which can only be defined by means of the collection as a whole. Thus, for example, the collection of propositions will be supposed to contain a proposition stating that “all propositions are either true or false.” It would seem, however, that such a statement could not be legitimate unless “all propositions” referred to some already definite collection, which it cannot do if new propositions are created by statements about “all propositions.” We shall, therefore, have to say that statements about “all propositions” are meaningless.… The principle which enables us to avoid illegitimate totalities may be stated as follows: “Whatever involves all of a collection must not be one of the collection”; or, conversely: “If, provided a certain collection had a total, it would have members only definable in terms of that total, then the said collection has no total.” We shall call this the “vicious-circle principle,” because it enables us to avoid the vicious circles involved in the assumption of illegitimate totalities. (Whitehead and Russell 1910, 37) (quoted in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Russell's Paradox) (Wikipedia).

Quickly fill in the unit circle by understanding reference angles and quadrants

👉 Learn about the unit circle. A unit circle is a circle which radius is 1 and is centered at the origin in the cartesian coordinate system. To construct the unit circle we take note of the points where the unit circle intersects the x- and the y- axis. The points of intersection are (1, 0

From playlist Trigonometric Functions and The Unit Circle

Trigonometry: Unit Circle

The unit circle plays a key role in understanding how circles and triangles are connected, as well as providing a simple way to introduce the basic trigonometric functions (sine, cosine and tangent). This video describes the unit circle very carefully with the goals of providing basic insi

From playlist Trigonometry

What is the unit circle

From playlist Evaluate Trigonometric Functions With The Unit Circle (ALG2)

How to memorize the unit circle

From playlist Evaluate Trigonometric Functions With The Unit Circle (ALG2)

Dyson Brownian motion, free fermions and connections to Random Matrix Theory-4 by Gregory Schehr

PROGRAM : BANGALORE SCHOOL ON STATISTICAL PHYSICS - XII (ONLINE) ORGANIZERS : Abhishek Dhar (ICTS-TIFR, Bengaluru) and Sanjib Sabhapandit (RRI, Bengaluru) DATE : 28 June 2021 to 09 July 2021 VENUE : Online Due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, the school will be conducted through online

From playlist Bangalore School on Statistical Physics - XII (ONLINE) 2021

Why the unit circle is so helpful for us to evaluate trig functions

From playlist Trigonometric Functions and The Unit Circle

Circles and Solids: Radius, Diameter, and Naming Solids

This video explains how to determine the radius and diameter of a circle. Various solids are also named.

From playlist Circles

You should know what Impredicativity is.

In this video I discuss the concept of predicativity, impredicativity and vicious circles. The text for the video is found in https://gist.github.com/Nikolaj-K/aae1f4bd582e60e6b7e5b5431fee054c

From playlist Logic

How Einstein Used Intellectual Play to Create Our View of Reality | Big Think

How Einstein Used Intellectual Play to Create Our View of Reality Watch the newest video from Big Think: https://bigth.ink/NewVideo Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: https://bigth.ink/Edge ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Scientif

From playlist Inside the mind of Albert Einstein | Big Think

3. Ways In and Out of the Hermeneutic Circle

Introduction to Theory of Literature (ENGL 300) In this lecture, Professor Paul Fry examines acts of reading and interpretation by way of the theory of hermeneutics. The origins of hermeneutic thought are traced through Western literature. The mechanics of hermeneutics, including the id

From playlist Introduction to Theory of Literature with Paul H. Fry

How to quickly write out the unit circle

From playlist Evaluate Trigonometric Functions With The Unit Circle (ALG2)

CERIAS Security: Signature Analysis Coupled With Slicing Analysis for the Validation of Software 1/3

Clip 1/3 Speaker: Adam Dugger · Arxan What if you could determine exactly where, in any compiled binary, a security threat existed? Answering this question has been the fundamental goal of anti-virus software for many years past, with limited success. Instead, what if you could determin

From playlist The CERIAS Security Seminars 2008

Learn how to construct the unit circle

From playlist Evaluate Trigonometric Functions With The Unit Circle (ALG2)

How to Think Like a Mathematician - with Eugenia Cheng

How does pure mathematics apply to our daily lives? Subscribe for regular science videos: http://bit.ly/RiSubscRibe Eugenia's book "The Art of Logic" is available now: https://geni.us/paUfA For thousands of years, mathematicians have used the timeless art of logic to see the world more c

From playlist Mathematics

How to Compete With Big Brands in Google [8.3]

In this video, you’ll learn how to compete with bigger companies in Google search. *************************************** Additional Blogging Resources Blogging For Business Course (Complete Playlist) ► https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y5kQXogrLN0&list=PLvJ_dXFSpd2tbI3mYhAO8oZ2NYMrJuNPq

From playlist Blogging for Business Course

10 - Lectures : Jean-Yves Girard 3/3, D'où vient la certitude ? (l'épidictique)

IHP thematic trimester : Semantics of proofs and certified mathematics 24/04/2014

From playlist T2-2014 : Semantics of proofs and certified mathematics

Watch me complete the unit circle

From playlist Evaluate Trigonometric Functions With The Unit Circle (ALG2)

26. Five Thoughts in Place of a Sweeing Conclusion

MIT 14.73 The Challenge of World Poverty, Spring 2011 View the complete course: http://ocw.mit.edu/14-73S11 Instructor: Abhijit Banerjee License: Creative Commons BY-NC-SA More information at http://ocw.mit.edu/terms More courses at http://ocw.mit.edu

From playlist MIT 14.73 The Challenge of World Poverty, Spring 2011

4 Varieties of Philosophical Skepticism - Kantian Skepticism

In this fourth lecture, James Conant continues to discuss and contrast Cartesian skepticism with Kantian skepticism, but particularly focuses on Kantian issues of perception and knowledge, and continues to discuss such via the work of C. I. Lewis. Unfortunately the audio isn't that good in

From playlist Varieties of Philosophical Skepticism - Cartesian vs Kantian

Parts of a Circle

Watch more videos on http://www.brightstorm.com/math/geometry SUBSCRIBE FOR All OUR VIDEOS! https://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=brightstorm2 VISIT BRIGHTSTORM.com FOR TONS OF VIDEO TUTORIALS AND OTHER FEATURES! http://www.brightstorm.com/ LET'S CONNECT! Facebook ► https

From playlist Geometry

Vicious circle principle

Related pages